The rule of the law presupposes the presumption of
publishing any data of public importance. When rejecting the disclosure of
given data, the state must show what legitimate interest it is pursuing. The
state’s decision to not make a relevant disclosure must be grounded in reason.
The Armenian government official announced yesterday through
a statement that it did not publish the data on the number of captives of the Armenian
side in Azerbaijan, and by way of justification, in its official response,
merely stated that the issue is one of a "super-sensitive nature."
This is not an acceptable approach.
In fact, the publication of the number of captives held by
the Armenian side in Azerbaijan will at least: 1) significantly increase
international pressure on Azerbaijan to release and return the captives, 2)
provide grounds for additional obligations of Azerbaijan, 3) increase the level
of protection of prisoners held in Azerbaijan, 4) demonstrate publicly and
emphasize the state's respect for the rights of prisoners and their families,
5) publicly emphasize the state's responsible attitude towards this issue of
public importance, and 6) finally, through such a stance, the state will be
eliminate or otherwise significantly reduce efforts and any attempts by either
side to manipulate and mislead the public with false information.
Therefore, the competent state body of the Republic of
Armenia must publish the number of prisoners of the Armenian side who,
according to the information at its disposal or in its belief, are currently
being held captive in Azerbaijan.