Our visits continued today in the town of Kapan, Syunik region
of the Republic of Armenia, Agarak, Yeghvard, Chakaten and other villages.
Surveys were carried out in the areas of the runways of the
administrative building of Kapan airport, in the immediate vicinity of which
are the Azerbaijani locations. Studies show that there are dangers not only for
the Kapan airport, but also for the interstate movement from Kapan to Yerevan
(M2) and a number of residential areas in the city of Kapan.
During a visit to Kapan Airport in the above-mentioned villages,
the on the spot Google and several other versions of online maps showed
different results, including in some cases the road from Kapan to Chakaten
village, as well as the road from Kapan Airport to Kapan Airport. The sections
in which the Azerbaijani forces are deployed, appeared to be representing to be
within the exclusive territory of the Republic of Armenia (RA).
Today's visits of the Human Rights Defender to the city and
villages of Kapan show that as a result of the approaches and methods used thus
far, and especially the mechanical use of Global Positioning System (GPS) or
Google maps, there are serious threats to the right to life and security of
border residents, for their physical security, for their mental health and
immunity, and for other rights of vital importance guaranteed by the
Constitution of the Republic of Armenia, some of which have already been
grossly violated. The security of the RA state borders is endangered.
In particular, by mechanical application of these principles,
various sections of the road from Kapan to Chakaten and other villages have
come under Azerbaijani control, which has put the movement of civilians in real
danger. At the same time, it must be taken into account that this road is
absolutely necessary for the security of the villages of Chakaten, Shikahogh,
Srashen, Nerkin Hand, Tsav, and for the vital rights of the inhabitants in the
region.
In addition, for example, in Chakaten, Agarak and Yeghvard,
people have simply been deprived of the opportunity to support themselves, and
of the use of the agricultural lands owned by them, and of their rights (for example,
for private or economic purposes as a garden, arable land, or pasture).
Moreover, these infringements also refer to such lands, for which the
certificates confirming the state registration of such rights, including
property rights, were issued either by Soviet Armenia, or by the competent
bodies of different periods of the Independent Republic of Armenia (Cadastre
Committee, etc.).
All the while, international rules of delimitation directly
require that when determining the state borders of a country, priority should
be given to the rights of border residents, their real estate and/or other
property. It is of critical necessity to ascertain in advance the persons who
will be deprived of their rights, to their apartments, lands, private business
interests and objectives, and other property due to the border demarcation
process. It must be borne in mind that they have a just right to compensation.
One of the priority tasks of the state in the process of
determining the borders is to solve the issues of ensuring the safe use of
forests and forest resources, as well as water resources necessary for the
vital needs of the border residents.
Therefore, the current approaches, and especially with respect
to matters of resolving the issues of Armenia's borders through GPS [Global
Positioning] system or Google (private) applications which endanger the
inviolability of Armenia's state borders and security, and so as to ensure the
rights of people living in our country and especially those of our border
residents, such a frame of reference which has been utilized thus far, is
absolutely unacceptable.
Today's meetings of the Human Rights Defender with the residents
of the border villages, the discussions and studies with the community bodies
confirm that the Azerbaijani military regularly appears on different sections
of the roads connecting the mentioned populated regions of the Republic of
Armenia, and does so in a provocative manner to intimidate the residents of
these communities.
The various researches of the Human Rights Defender's staff show
that in Kapan, Agarak, Yeghvard and other settlements which have been
transformed to border areas, the residents do not have credible information
pertaining to the determination of the borders and their respective rights.
This creates uncertainty, and it creates an atmosphere of alarm and anxiety
among civilians.
During today's visit, important meetings were held with the
Mayor of Kapan, Yeghvard, Agarak, and heads of a number of a number of other
rural communities, community bodies, and the residents of these communities, as
well as the staff of the RA Armed Forces and the NSS border troops.
During today's visits, the Human Rights Defender's Office also
obtained the relevant facts necessary for the protection of human rights in
specific situations, in connection with which separate summaries will be made
and the necessary measures will be taken.
A visit to Meghri is scheduled for tomorrow.
Arman Tatoyan
The Human Rights Defender of Armenia
Հայերեն
